Today, it seems like nearly everyone is caught up in either utopian dreams or dystopian nightmares about AI. It feels like it’s almost gotten to the point where you can’t pick up a science fiction story or watch SF on the large or small screens without coming across exaggerated scenarios projecting humanity’s highest hopes or worst fears about what may be coming in artificial intelligence.
Where the Axe is Buried, one of 14 works nominated for the next Prometheus Award for Best Novel, takes a more intelligent, balanced, nuanced and realistic view of such possibilities.
Where all too often such AI-themed novels uncritically embrace one extreme or the other, Ray Nayler’s post-apocalyptic utopian/dystopian tale probes both scenarios from an anti-authoritarian, very human and humane perspective. His novel is notable for finding both extremes lacking from the standpoints of community, common decency and personal liberty.
In a gripping but sobering narrative highlighting libertarian themes of resistance to tyranny and human endurance under oppression, Nayler ultimately rejects such wishful social engineering as an unattractive prescription for suffering and stagnation.
